March 26, 2019 read, explore

What Does The Constitution Say About Surveillance?

The Constitution provides American citizens with certain rights that are not to be infringed upon by the government. It seems as time goes on, the government of the United States tries to infringe further and further on its citizens’ rights. Indiscriminate government surveillance is just one piece of the infringement pie.    

It’s a sad truth that our freedoms as Americans are evaporating. Since the Twin Towers were attacked, Americans have lost liberties in the name of security. Laws such as the Patriot Act were passed with the hope that they would stop future terrorist attacks. So far, surveillance under the Patriot Act has proved ineffective. It was a law that was passed 45 days after the attack on the Twin Towers and wasn’t thought out. Fear was the motivator in the passing of the law.

“The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”

The Fourth Amendment to our Constitution provides protection from warrantless, indiscriminate government surveillance. The courts are beginning to side with the Constitution. In late 2013, as ProPublica reported, that U.S. District Court Judge Richard Leon ruled the NSA bulk phone metadata collection was likely unconstitutional.

More recently, a federal appeals court ruled the NSA phone metadata collection illegal. The ruling was made just last month by a three-judge panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit.

The government had argued that it was only collecting relevant information. Information that could in theory stop a terrorist plot. The unanimous court opinion had a different view on information’s relevancy.

“The interpretation urged by the government would require a drastic expansion of the term ‘relevance,’ not only with respect to § 215, but also as that term is construed for purposes of subpoenas, and of a number of national security-related statutes, to sweep further than those statutes have ever been thought to reach,”

The Patriot Act recently expired thanks to Senator Rand Paul. A similar bill was passed soon after its expiration. The replacement law adds a few restrictions to the Patriot Act, but leaves much of it intact.

If an objective person were to read the Constitution, and then consider the Patriot Act, they would know that the two documents were conflicting one another.

 

US Congress Passes Surveillance Reform Bill

 

This article was originally published November 11, 2013 but has undergone major editing. 

 

[Photo © Oatboat.com]

Related Posts

Trump’s First 100 Days in Office Will be Telling

Donald Trump has been busy working with his transition team in order to establish policy that he wants to enact...

#GoldenShowerGate: 5 Allegations BuzzFeed Article Made Against Donald Trump

If you haven’t heard, BuzzFeed–the site known for quizzes with names like ‘We Know How Many Kids You’ll Have Based...

What Impact Will Brexit Have On The Gaming Industry?

A lot changed after the British public voted to leave the European Union on June 23. The value of the...

Donald Trumps Call To Criminalize Flag-burning Is Ridiculous

I was hoping that President-elect Trump would fight for liberty as many of his positions have suggested (minus his stance...

Is Trump’s Claim That Millions Voted Illegally Completely Crazy?

If you’ve been paying attention to any of the major news outlets, you know that Trump made a claim that...

Why Trump Has To Be A Great President

I haven’t heard many people talk about the possibility of President-elect Donald Trump actually being a good president. Most of...

Michael Moore’s Plan To Beat Trump Is Adorable

In the wake of Trump’s major upset victory, Michael Moore (who predicted Trumps win) took to Facebook to make a...

Why We’re Endorsing Donald Trump For President

The country is once again nearing the point at which we elect our new president. This is the first time...

Will Trump Recover From His Post-convention Spiral?

If you’ve visited any political website or news channel in the last week, you’ve heard a lot about polls. The...

Beyond Background Checks: More Ways to Stop Gun Violence

In the 212 days since the start of 2016, there have been 271 mass shootings in the United States. While...

Think Twice Before Voting Green in 2016

This election cycle, Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) has ignited a political revolution that, despite his withdrawal from the Democratic primaries, has...

Auditing the Fed: What It Really Means

The Republican Party’s new official platform returned to many traditional (and what many would call outdated) ideas and principles, like...

Why Ted Cruz Might Be the GOP’s 2020 Nominee

In a convention that was filled with chaos and controversy, from Melania Trump’s alleged plagiarism of Michelle Obama to Chris...

Does The U.S. Really Have The Highest Taxes In The World?

Donald Trump says America has the highest taxes in the world. There are two problems with this claim. First, it’s...

Has Pope Francis Really Done More For Peace in Three Years Than The UN Has Since 1945?

If there’s one word that comes to mind when one hears the name Pope Francis, that word is “rebel.” Since...

Comments
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *